Friday, June 2, 2017

Drawing parallels between AC3 and GITS: analysis of animation, setting and themes

The Ghost in the Shell movie and Ace Combat 3: Electrosphere are my favorite anime film and video-game respectively. In time I started noticing similarities between them, enough to make me want to dive in and elaborate on the threads that these two works have in common.

Introduction

The Ghost in the Shell movie, released in 1995, is based on the manga of the same by Shirow Masamune and was directed by Mamoru Oshii. Its plot is set in 2029 A.D. in Hong Kong and revolves around a manhunt for a famous hacker known only as The Puppetmaster. Major Motoko Kusanagi, of the counter-terrorism unit Section 9, is tasked with finding him or her and bringing them to justice.

Ace Combat 3 Electrosphere is an original work by Namco and was released in 1999. The electrosphere is an information network similar to current day Internet. Its futuristic world and setting were created by Dai Satō (from his company Frognation) and integrated with elements from the previous game, Ace Combat 2. The game takes place in 2040 with the player beginning as a fighter pilot for a peacekeeping organization that tries maintain peace after the two leading multinational corporations go to war, engulfing the whole country of USEA.

Staff, designs and animation

The fact that Production I.G was in charge of producing the animation for AC3 is well known and was part of its marketing campaign in Japan. This was the fourth collaboration between Namco and Production I.G, after two 'Tales" games and Tekken 3, and the thirteenth game that they would work on after entering the video-game arena with the Ghost in the Shell game for the PSX in 1996.

Other studios that Production I.G employed for the animation in AC3 that also helped make the GITS movie are I.G Niigata, Ashi Production and Studio Wombat.

Because the two productions were only a few years apart, some artists who worked on GITS also worked on creating designs and animation for AC3.

Mechanical designer Atsushi Takeuchi
Atsushi Takeuchi is the name I find most recognizable. He not only did Mechanical Designs, Layout and Key Animation for GITS. He was Mechanical Designer for AC3 and also storyboarded the Opening Movie. He shares Mechanical Design credits with Namco's Kei Yoshimizu, who's also credited as Concept Designer and as Director and Storyboard Artist for CG Movie Development.

He had an important part in designing the original aircraft of AC3, a futuristic range of aircraft called R-numeral (the R stands for radical). His AC3 designs are similar to his work in Sol Bianca (1, 2), especially the R-352 (top right) and R-103 (bottom right). Here are some of his designs:

Concept art: 1, 2, 3, 4
CG movie renders: 1, 2, 3, 4
In-game models: 1, 2, 3, 4
Animated HD GIF of the R-103: 1

Other names shared by both productions are:
Kayoko Nabeta: In-betweens and Key Animation for GITS; Key Animation for AC3.
Yasuhiro Oshima: Key Animation for GITS and Animation Director for Animation Character Design in AC3.
Hiroyo Izumi: did In-betweens for GITS and for AC3.

Another important staff member is 3D CG director Tokumitsu Kifune, who filled the same position for the GITS video game and AC3. He would later direct the 3D animation for Innocence.

Below are two samples that showcase Production I.G's digitally generated animation and seamless integration of 3D with 2D that helps enhance the realism of the scene. Click the stills to watch the animations.

Another technique used in GITS present in AC3 is the use of POV shots as if the viewer were looking through the lens of a camera. that is down to Animation Director Daisuke Chiba who also story-boarded the anime cut-scenes for AC3. He did not work on the GITS movie but was Assistant Unit Director on Patlabor 2 the Movie (1993), another work that featured extensive use of POV shots. In AC3 a two-minute scene is shown entirely with this method. Here are two additional examples:
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-3PkpMr46Cgw/WSZf0SCMIpI/AAAAAAAAI3w/1jTXfj8aiF0meJg1FN86sAPaLIQ2rub-QCLcB/s1600/POV1.gif https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-k8ZkXdC2_Uk/WSZf6YMRJ-I/AAAAAAAAI30/vcgFYXNp8MwAVFhem1JcAdDVEoJFRbfLACLcB/s1600/POV2.gif
Note the expert use of this technique in the second example. We first look through the eyes of a human being, we see communication, movement and in the frame the most prominent colors are warm. Then a transition* happens and we start seeing these two characters from a different point of view, with us being moved away from them and the colors now are much cooler. After that we're taken out of this POV shot to reveal that we were looking through the lens of a camera. This shot has a bit of a visual gag as the camera we're now seeing refocuses its lens similarly to the sight of a person with their eyes wide open as during a moment of discovery or surprise.

*This transition represents the birth of an electronic copy of the man named Dision seen in the video. This process is called "Sublimation" in AC3's world and is not commonplace.  

The two GIFs below show two more ways in which Production I.G made use of this POV shot to tell the story, this time to simulate us looking at a television or the news. The one on the left happens during one of the game's endings where we see news broadcast and as the cut-scene ends we zoom out and a re-creation of a CRT TV being turned off ends the scene. This is used for the last shot of every ending movie as a means to foreshadow the final reveal of the game, where we find out that this was all part of a computer program.
https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-uoFC9icWRxM/WSajJr7u8tI/AAAAAAAAI4Y/9pe3y86r0osqL-NDqYQFDadx0oR5P7dqQCPcB/s1600/TV1.gif https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-jgdFTCeiMBk/WSajknGCzfI/AAAAAAAAI4k/pdZBU1P5z4Y_V8fx-Mf2_Zn-cwgqXEDhgCLcB/s1600/TV2.gif
The second example happens during a different ending, where a surviving character watches the news and then turns off the TV. The same effect is then used one more time at the very end of the cut-scene as in the other endings, further layering the scene.

Choices like these serve to complement one crucial aspect of Namco's design. Things such as menus and loading screens and even the design of the game discs themselves, usually all taken for granted, are all designed as integral parts of the game's actual setting, casually hinting at the story behind the story, as a digital veil that separates what's real in the game from what isn't, and going a step further, the player from the game.

Introducing the characters

Rena
Dision
Cynthia
Rena is a young pilot who was part of a secret project for a next-generation fighter jet called Night Raven. Her body was modified to allow her to control it via a computer-synaptic interface.

Dision as we meet him is an electronic copy of a real ace pilot who died in a bombing attack. His goal is to make everyone like him and destroy those who oppose him.

Cynthia is a scientist-cum-pilot who dreams of becoming a life-form made of pure information like Dision, something she believes to be the next evolutionary stage of mankind.

Motoko
The Puppetmaster
Motoko is the squad leader of Public Security Section 9. She used to be human but is now almost a complete cyborg except for some human brain cells in her body. She doubts ever being human and wishes to leave her artificial body because she feels limited by it.

The Puppetmaster AKA Project 2501 is an A.I. created for intelligence-gathering and data manipulation. After becoming self-aware it goes rogue and offers to merge with Motoko as a means of self-preservation and evolution.

Settings, themes and terminology

To start off this section, it's important to address in which ways the worlds featured in GITS and AC3 converge and diverge:

Both feature a story centered around A.I., hackers and megacorporations. Both also feature advanced technology and scientific achievements.

In AC3 however, cyborgs are a no-show while in GITS it's common to be partially a cyborg or even be working with actual cybernetic beings. The closest we get to that in AC3 is a small augmentation made to one character, very distant from the cyber-brains of GITS. Nonetheless, Production I.G didn't miss this opportunity to make a visual nod to the GITS movie.

Think-tanks do not exist in AC3 but it being a flight-shooting game set in the future, it obviously features unmanned aircraft controlled by human operators and by A.I, the last of which do not have voices of their own as in GITS.

AC3's vision of the near-future is also cleaner and seemingly more positive. There are also no signs of nuclear fallout and wars are not waged with nuclear weapons, unlike in the GITS manga. In fact they're not mentioned at all during the game's story.

And while in GITS governments and the rule of law are still intact, in AC3's USEA a radical structural change occurred after multi-national corporations became so big and powerful that they would take over the role previously occupied by elected governments. No characters comment on this but one news broadcast in the game give the impression that this alarming fact is taken for granted, probably because it's from the same monolithic company (shades of RoboCop here).

One last point before jumping to the character section is that it's important to note how the good guys in GITS work for the government (Public Security Section 9) while in AC3 they work for an NGO, the Neo United Nations, due to the conspicuous absence of the state as an actor. On a surface level they're mostly the same: people who work for the people and their safety.

But ideologically they couldn't be more different. GITS assures us that states will prevail despite shifts in the balance of power and nuclear wars, while AC3 gives us a world where they were not capable of resisting the growth and sheer economic power of multi-national corporations (sadly realistic). The only solution in this possible future lies with an NGO, which by definition cannot act in the interest of profits and cannot advocate the use of violence, that AC3 pushes to science-fiction extremes as a substitute for the government, not just filling gaps left by its inabilities but as the last actor or heir to the responsibilities that once lay in the hands of a state elected by the people. A stark contrast to the powerful corporations where "vote with your wallet" is the order of the day.

Unlike GITS, in AC3 world powers do not exist, only economic powers who fight until there's only one left, the rest be damned.
"...when I was a child, I wanted to become a machine. No matter how sick I got—even if I died, I could be repaired. I wanted a body like that."
Rena is girl who resents her body because she was born with a sickness that doesn't allow her to be out in the sun and leaves her body weaker. After receiving an augmentation, she's allowed to make her dream of flying come true, in her case through a spectacular piece of machinery, the Night Raven, but at the same time also a weapon. Because of her relationship with her body and machines, she starts thinking more and more about uniting her mind with the wings that gave her life meaning, leaving her fragile body, and earthly existence, as an after-thought.

"I feel confined, only free to expand myself within boundaries."
Motoko walks the same line but on the other side going in the opposite direction. She appreciates the high-tech advantages, and disadvantages, that having such a body entails, but in the end she still feels limited by it. In the end, even though physically she's barely human, she cares very much about what it means to be human and living life as a human being.
___

Cynthia dreams of going beyond the limits of a physical existence to live as pure information, similar to what happens to Motoko at the end of the GITS movie. Both agree that it's a more fulfilling and less restricting way of living their lives.

"...the coming world everyone should advance into. Yes, I want to discover a domain composed of alien perceptions and feelings, of which no one has yet experienced. It is this flesh, necessary for us to live, that has put a limit on an existence so steeped in mystery as the soul and psyche." - Cynthia to her sister Fiona as they argue about her signing up as a test subject for a Sublimation test at her company.

"We have been subordinate to our limitations. The time has come to cast aside these bonds and to elevate our consciousness to a higher plane. It is time to become a part of all things." - Project 2501 to Motoko before they merge into a new entity.

Dision's terrorist organization, Ouroboros, uses similar phrasing to describe the human condition during their manifesto: "The limit of humanity is your body, bound by its desires!"
___

The two works also use similar terminology to describe their information networks. Cynthia and Project 2501 use the same expression to describe the information network and the electrosphere: 情報の海 (Jōhō no umi, lit. sea of information) and エレクトロスフィアの海 (erekutorosufia no umi, lit. sea of electrosphere)
___ 

Another interesting curiosity about GITS and AC3 is how their endings end up being quite similar. At the end of GITS, Motoko/2501 is finally free to live as a new entity in an information network that's vast and infinite. In AC3, the player character Nemo (an A.I.), is set free by its creator into the real world. A new game begins for Nemo, the so-called game of life, unrestricted by pre-determined paths, or destinies, free to absorb information at will for it to answer such important and cryptic questions as "Who created this world, and why?".

After the shows are over the viewer is left with the impression that there's a literal world of possibilities ahead for our characters while at the same time drawing a parallel between their sci-fi worlds and our own.

Conclusion

While writing this post I was able to gain a better understanding of the impact Production I.G had on AC3. My take on Namco's decision to pick them to produce the anime for AC3 is they were the perfect choice because of their pioneer work in the field of digital animation and the nature of the story that Namco wanted to tell, which intersects with some interesting aspects covered in the GITS movie. There's no denying that AC3 is clearly informed by cyberpunk works such as, but not limited to, GITS, making it a piece of entertainment made for a demographic that includes those who enjoy such works of fiction.

The scope of the game was ambitious, being a veritable quantum leap from previous games, and while its success domestically wasn't proportional to their efforts (like GITS), the resulting package shows a total commitment to their vision, for which they spared no expense in realizing. Because of this it's a sophisticated work that has stood the test of time for almost 20 years, and counting.

2 comments:

  1. Incredibly well written post!

    I'm glad to see, GITS and AC3 are my two favourites too!

    ReplyDelete